Understanding the Prosperity Gospel in Africa: Risks and Realities in the African and Diaspora Contexts
The Prosperity Gospel, often called the “Health and Wealth Gospel,” is a theological concept that has experienced explosive growth across the African continent and within the global African diaspora. While its proponents argue it offers hope and financial liberation, a critical, evidence-based analysis reveals significant economic, psychological, and ethical dangers for communities already grappling with historical and systemic vulnerabilities.
Learn How to Leverage Your Story through our Story To Asset Framework.
In this deep-dive analysis, building on the insights of Professor Oluwafemi Esan, we examine the Dangers of Prosperity through a multidimensional framework. The analysis draws on biblical concepts of work while revealing the real-world harm caused by the false promise of instant, faith-driven wealth.
Professor Esan, a regular guest on the Obehi Podcast, offered valuable perspectives on The Psychological and Economic Dangers of the Prosperity Gospel in Africa, all in helping to illuminate the complex intersections between belief, vulnerability, and exploitation.
Known for hosting leading thinkers from across the African diaspora, Obehi Ewanfoh highlights voices from diverse fields such as spirituality, history, business, culture, and leadership.
With more than 1,000 interviews to his name, he has built a respected and dynamic platform dedicated to exploring African knowledge systems, global Black experiences, and the complex realities that shape them.
The African Context: Legacy, Heritage, and Vulnerability
To understand the impact of the Prosperity Gospel, we must first contextualize it within the historical and economic realities of Africa and the Diaspora.
Legacy of Economic Dispossession
The enduring Legacy of colonialism, slavery, and persistent structural adjustment policies has resulted in a continent where a significant portion of the population faces economic precarity.
Poverty and Inequality:
According to data from the World Bank and various national statistical offices, Sub-Saharan Africa is home to a disproportionate share of the world’s extremely poor.
High youth unemployment rates, weak formal labor markets, and reliance on the volatile informal sector create a pervasive environment of financial anxiety.
The Psychological Vacuum:
This economic instability creates a psychological vacuum, a deep need for hope, immediate relief, and a sense of control over one’s destiny. The Prosperity Gospel fills this void by offering a seemingly divine solution to earthly suffering, bypassing the arduous, slow process of systemic change and traditional economic development.
The Misappropriation of African Principles
The Heritage of many African cultures is built on core ethical frameworks like Ubuntu, which emphasizes community, interdependence, and shared responsibility (“I am because we are”). However, the Prosperity Gospel often promotes a theology of radical individualism:
Individual Salvation vs. Collective Upliftment:
The focus shifts from collective economic progress and mutual aid (a traditional African value) to the individual’s pursuit of wealth, often framing a neighbor’s poverty as a sign of their lack of faith or an un-broken “curse.” This fractures community solidarity and discourages critique of systemic inequality.
The Erroneous Economic Theology
The core danger of the Prosperity Gospel lies in its fundamental misunderstanding—or deliberate misrepresentation, of the relationship between work, faith, and material blessing.
It replaces a robust Biblical Psychology of Work with a speculative Biblical Economics that promises wealth through sacrificial financial giving (seed-sowing).
The True Hebrew Concept of Work (Avodah)
The biblical narrative, which is foundational to the gospel movement, presents a very different view of economic activity.
The Hebrew word avodah (עֲבֹודָה) is critical here. As Professor Esan’s notes highlight, avodah means “work,” “worship,” and “service.”
| Hebrew Term | Primary Concept | Implication for Life |
| $Avodah$ (עֲבֹודָה) | Work, Worship, Service | All productive labor is a spiritual act, serving God and humanity (Genesis 2:15). |
| Genesis 3:19 | “Sweat of your brow” | Material gain is typically the result of hard, persistent, physical labor—not a direct, instant reward for a financial contribution. |
| Colossians 3:23 | “Work heartily, as for the Lord” | The value of work is in the effort, diligence, and service to God, irrespective of the size of the financial reward. |
The Misapplication:
The Prosperity Gospel detaches avodah, substituting them with a transaction: give money and receive divine wealth.
This promotes a culture that devalues vocational excellence and long-term investment in skills, education, and ethical enterprise.
The Economic Drain: Seeding and The Tithe
The movement’s financial model is a direct economic drain on the most vulnerable members of society.
Regressive Taxation:
The practice of encouraging tithing (10% of income) and, more dangerously, “seed-sowing” (giving beyond the tithe for a breakthrough) acts as a highly regressive tax.
For someone earning a stable salary, a 10% tithe is manageable; for a woman operating a small, low-margin business in the informal sector, a significant offering can collapse her venture.
Investment Displacement:
The money given as a “seed” is money that is displaced from economically productive activities:
- Education: Paying school fees for children.
- Health: Purchasing necessary medication.
- Investment: Re-investing in the individual’s business or farm.
Instead of building durable human and financial capital, these scarce resources are redirected to the church’s leadership and infrastructure, which often offers little to no immediate social safety net or productive return for the congregants.
Financial Ruin:
Multiple studies and investigative reports document cases where believers have sold their homes, land, or last remaining assets, following a pastor’s instruction to “sow a giant seed” to break a generational curse or unlock a massive blessing.
When the promised wealth does not materialize, the psychological and economic devastation is profound, often leading to debt, destitution, and family breakdown.
The Psychological and Ethical Dangers
Beyond the purely economic impact, the Prosperity Gospel inflicts deep psychological damage and undermines ethical governance.
The Dangers of Erroneous Attribution – The theology creates a self-reinforcing cycle of shame and hopelessness by linking material reality directly to spiritual standing.
Victim Blaming:
If a believer remains poor, sick, or faces persistent challenges, the message implies a failure of faith.
This places the entire burden of poverty on the individual’s spiritual inadequacy, completely ignoring the structural barriers (e.g., poor infrastructure, corruption, lack of access to credit, historical injustice) that are the true root causes.
This is a severe psychological blow, replacing structural critique with crippling self-blame.
The Focus on Miracles:
An overemphasis on immediate, miraculous financial breakthroughs discourages the determination, responsibility, problem-solving, and self-control that are essential for long-term economic development, as highlighted in the Professor’s notes.
It fosters a dependency on the church leader, the conduit of the “blessing”, rather than personal agency and strategic planning.
The Political and Governance Impact
The wealth accumulated by Prosperity Gospel leaders, often tax-free and with minimal public accountability, can also corrupt the Political Structures of African nations.
Exemption from Scrutiny:
Highly influential pastors often operate outside the purview of fiscal and political accountability.
Their amassed wealth grants them political access and influence, allowing them to lobby against regulations that might restrict their financial operations or tax their income, ultimately undermining good governance.
The Normalization of Extravagance:
By showcasing and celebrating exorbitant wealth, private jets, mansions, luxury cars, as a sign of God’s favor, these leaders set a dangerous precedent.
See also Awakened With New Beats: How Mr Eazi And Other African Artists Are Redefining The Creative Economy
It subtly endorses the idea that leadership, whether religious or political, should be associated with unchecked personal enrichment, rather than public service and ethical stewardship, which goes against fundamental African Principles of ethical leadership.
The Way Forward: Reaffirming Ethical and Economic Foundations
For the African continent and the diaspora, countering the dangers of the Prosperity Gospel requires a return to foundational ethical and economic principles:
Promoting Avodah:
Re-emphasizing the true biblical and historical African understanding of work as worship, service, and skill development. Promoting entrepreneurship, vocational training, and quality education as the primary, God-honored path to sustainable wealth creation.
Focus on Systemic Justice:
Religious and community leaders must pivot the focus from individual financial curses to structural economic injustices.
This includes advocating for political reform, anti-corruption measures, and investment in public goods like healthcare, infrastructure, and education, the true engines of collective prosperity (Isaiah 61:11, as quoted by Professor Esan, speaks of the Sovereign LORD making righteousness and praise spring up before all nations, a collective, holistic vision).
Financial Literacy:
Integrating financial literacy, budgeting, and ethical investment education into community and religious programming to empower individuals to build durable wealth and recognize manipulative financial appeals.
The Prosperity Gospel, in its erroneous form, is a sophisticated psycho-economic trap. It exploits the legitimate desire for a better life by substituting diligent labor, ethical investment, and structural change with a transactional theology that ultimately benefits only a select few at the expense of the collective economic well-being and psychological health of the African community.
Learn How to Leverage Your Story through our Story To Asset Framework.
